About Us
Lancaster
Independent Insurance Agents
Lancaster Insurance Agency is honored to have been serving the tri-state area for more than 70 years. We possess the experience and know how to give you the best insurance products to meet your needs in personal or business ventures. Molly O’Daniel is a 4th Generation insurance management service provider.
Our Mission
Our mission is to be your support system and to arm you with accurate information to help you make the right insurance coverage decisions. Whether you are insuring your home, vehicle or business, we’re here to help protect your future with the expertise our clients have come to expect. What a nice, secure feeling it is to know that you’re fully covered with services from Lancaster Insurance Agency.
Molly O'Daniel
President
Molly was born and raised in Evansville, and she is passionate about providing for her community. She enjoys getting to know her customers on an individual basis and she feels strongly about educating her customers about their policies in order for them to make educated decisions regarding their respective insurance needs. It brings Molly joy to be able to provide customers with a backup plan, should an unfortunate event occur. Outside of the agency, you will find Molly at community events, spending time outdoors with her dog and her fiancé, cooking, exercising, or spending time with her family.
Dylan Krohn
Agent
Dylan joins Lancaster Insurance as an agent who’s main priority is to protect you and your family from the unpredictable. Dylan is an Evansville resident and grew up in Posey County. In his free time you can find him on the golf course, walking with his fiance and their dog Angler, or helping families with their dreams of home ownership as a realtor with FC Tucker. Dylan has an extensive background in sales and making sure his clients get what they need in order to live a happier life. He understands that everyone’s needs are different and is able and ready to make sure they are all met!
Kimber sawyer
Agent
Kimber was born and raised in Evansville and graduated from Bosse High School. She left the area when she got married and raised 2 sons. Her youngest graduated from USI, which brought her back to Evansville to live in 2013.
She loves her job at Lancaster Insurance and is devoted to her customers to provide the appropriate coverage for the best price to give her customers the peace of mind that they are covered.
In her spare time she loves playing board games with her kids and cards with her friends. She is also on a trivia team.
Integrity, Information & Innovation
We'll Help You Plan Ahead
Protection takes planning, and you can trust our insurance agents to provide you with coverage for personal or commercial vehicle use, homeowner, renter, or dwelling packages, and small business coverage that includes liability and worker’s compensation insurance. Contact us today to learn more.
Let's Talk
Independent Insurance Agents | Evansville, IN
70+ Years of Experience
We’re a private agency for many different insurance providers and specialize in finding policies that are right for you. Whether you require auto, home, or business insurance, we will discuss your policy options with you to make sure you have everything that you need.